-
Dear forum reader,
To actively participate in our forum discussions or to start your own threads, in addition to your game account you need a forum account. You can REGISTER HERE!
Please ensure a translation in to English is provided if your post is not in English and to respect your fellow players when posting.
Feedback Try out Guild Perks on Beta!
- Thread starter Juber
- Start date
Donna a Macskabolond
Merchant
Yes, I figured it out
)But my opinion remained the same. There is not even one for big, prospering gulilds which worth its cost.
For smaller gulids one or two would be useful, but the cost is too high for them, not to mention you have 21 days to develop the perk and to enjoy the reward.
CrashBoom
Legend
I think the system should be changed:
current:
we pay during the cycle and when reaching a level we get it until the end of the current cycle
so most likely when we reach level 3 for the 3 activated perks the cycle is over
my suggestion
in the current cycle we pay for perk of the next cycle
the advantage would be: then we get the full 3 weeks to benefit from it
disadvantage would be: in the first cycle we get nothing. but that is only a starting problem
current:
we pay during the cycle and when reaching a level we get it until the end of the current cycle
so most likely when we reach level 3 for the 3 activated perks the cycle is over
my suggestion
in the current cycle we pay for perk of the next cycle
the advantage would be: then we get the full 3 weeks to benefit from it
disadvantage would be: in the first cycle we get nothing. but that is only a starting problem
Owl II
Emperor
Amdira
Baronet
Thanks - I was so close
Devilsangel
Baronet
Interested only in Glory match IF it works with alcatraz....did we get an answer to that?
Emberguard
Emperor
Well this is interesting....
If we can donate to absolutely everything, are we able to swap which ones are active midway through the cycle or.....?
If we can donate to absolutely everything, are we able to swap which ones are active midway through the cycle or.....?
CrashBoom
Legend
vikingraider
Squire
Tavern sweeper - visiting a *guild member* tavern? Most people dont have guild members of their friend list
Emberguard
Emperor
Well this is interesting....
If we can donate to absolutely everything, are we able to swap which ones are active midway through the cycle or.....?
@Juber would it be possible for the devs to explore reallocating donated resources within the perks?
Idea for how it could be implemented:
- Only the first three perks donated to can continue to be donated towards (so we're not wasting resources donating to everything)
- Because each perk has the exact same resources required, allow all resources from a single perk to be transferred to a completely empty perk.
- For balancing purposes, we could restrict swapping of perks to only being available while a perk is in Level 0
AGranolaBar
Squire
Now that I have seen it, as it is, zero interest, sorry.
I tried to like it but mathematically what we put in does not get returned.
I tried to like it but mathematically what we put in does not get returned.
Hansueli50
Farmer
Waste of time and effort dear Inno, pls spend your time on the bug's that's more beneficial to the game, than this idee
Emberguard
Emperor
Alternative Solution:
Instead of donating to specific perks, donate to slots #1, #2 and #3.
Allow each individual player to choose their own perks. Donations go towards how many Perk slots are active, not which Perks.
Idea Mockup:
jovada
Regent
VENI,VIDI, and GONI
The bonus you get is not worth all the donations, and really "prosper city" you have to donate tons of coins and supplies to gain a 10% coins and supplies haha.
Besides you can't expect from smaller players they do 30 donations every day, so this will go on the shoulders of the bigger players and after a few months they will be broke to haha.
The bonus you get is not worth all the donations, and really "prosper city" you have to donate tons of coins and supplies to gain a 10% coins and supplies haha.
Besides you can't expect from smaller players they do 30 donations every day, so this will go on the shoulders of the bigger players and after a few months they will be broke to haha.
BestWarrior
Baronet
Not interesting at all... it's just another big mess for most part of guild members! waste os time and resources in my opinion. Please turn the game more challenging again
Emberguard
Emperor
I think the main issue there is that it resets after 3 weeks. If progress were retained but you could only choose which 3 to activate every 3 weeks then the cost would be less of an issue due to being a once off thing.
But I'm guessing the reason it's able to scale costs at all is the resetting cycle. So if that changed you'd probably also have to change how costs are determined which could mean having players unlocking perks independently from each other, or a set shared priced for the entire guild
MJ Artisan of War
Baronet
i don't see any value in these perks, high cost for a tiny return and a reset every 3 weeks....
i did not think they could come up with a dumber idea than the Event Hub monstrosity...
Inno did surprise me in that regard.....
i did not think they could come up with a dumber idea than the Event Hub monstrosity...
Inno did surprise me in that regard.....