DeletedUser4446
Guest
Yes, and yes.
-
Dear forum reader,
To actively participate in our forum discussions or to start your own threads, in addition to your game account you need a forum account. You can REGISTER HERE!
Please ensure a translation in to English is provided if your post is not in English and to respect your fellow players when posting.
Feedback [Feedback] New Rankings
- Thread starter Sovereign
- Start date
BestWarrior
Baronet
But i've made a donation and i've got any ranking points. Are you sure about that "yes"?
DeletedUser
Guest
you don't get points when donating to other
you don't get points immediately when donating to your own GB
you get points when one of your GB reaches the next level
depending on the needed FP for the level no matter who donated the FP to the GB
you don't get points immediately when donating to your own GB
you get points when one of your GB reaches the next level
depending on the needed FP for the level no matter who donated the FP to the GB
BestWarrior
Baronet
Thank you BetaTest, that's what i thought, but there was some confusion here about that.
HuscarlTW
Squire
If I were to take a wild guess, I'd say that I've gathered somewhere in the ballpark of 1 billion coins and 300 million supplies over time, in my main city.
1,300,000,000 / 300 = 4,333,333 points lost to the new ranking
And to compensate me I get a piddly boost to my score from goods spent (maybe 1-2M) and a 640,000 point statue.
This ranking update is going to trash my total score (currently at 6.6M). If I'm lucky I'll lose 1/3 of my points.
1,300,000,000 / 300 = 4,333,333 points lost to the new ranking
And to compensate me I get a piddly boost to my score from goods spent (maybe 1-2M) and a 640,000 point statue.
This ranking update is going to trash my total score (currently at 6.6M). If I'm lucky I'll lose 1/3 of my points.
DeletedUser4256
Guest
yesterday I was at #198, today after recalculation #186
and finally after building the Silver award (+659 happiness, +409,600 points) I've moved up to #147
Not bad at all
and finally after building the Silver award (+659 happiness, +409,600 points) I've moved up to #147
Not bad at all
DeletedUser4446
Guest
I have gained about 70 ranking places, and another 40 after I put down the statue. I'm now up to 140-ish on the rank.
Coins/supplies points are lost, but city points for the buildings in your city have increased a lot.
That, plus the goods points, ended up actually increasing my ranking.
I ended up with 600,000 more points than I had before (before placing the award).
So I can't complain.
Coins/supplies points are lost, but city points for the buildings in your city have increased a lot.
That, plus the goods points, ended up actually increasing my ranking.
I ended up with 600,000 more points than I had before (before placing the award).
So I can't complain.
vidicecilia
Baronet
People who gained places also received an statue? It´s funny.
I won´t put this statue at my city. It is the symbol of FoE abuse.
I want to see the calculations. Of course I won't be able.
I won´t put this statue at my city. It is the symbol of FoE abuse.
I want to see the calculations. Of course I won't be able.
DeletedUser4446
Guest
They're all here in this thread.
HuscarlTW
Squire
Wouldn't this be 9 points per FP? That's a 900 point gain from a 100 FP expenditure. Where are people coming up with 15 points per FP?
Edit: nvm... I'm thinking of level 1 to 2
New question... do your FPs count for more points on high level GBs? I can imagine that an iron age player with a level 10 Zeus/Babel would be significantly ahead in ranking compared to his neighbors who have low levels on these GBs. Specifically, this player would have 75,000 points more than if he didn't own these GBs. While that isn't a lot in later ages, that's massive early on.
Last edited:
Rob Farmer III
Squire
Am I supposed to get points from Goods collected by the Dynamic Tower during AIDing? I had 15 bonuses and scored 0 points.
Lionhead
Baronet
I have since the new ranking-system came today levelled an InnoTower and a Colosseum. Both gave an increase in my pointscore of 15 points per fp needed for level-change.
Lionhead
Baronet
You don´t get any points for goods collected. Only goods spent.
DeletedUser5902
Guest
If you trade 1FE good @21pts down at the FOE calculator rate you get 50 IA goods
50 IA goods @3pts/each = 150pts
Forget about making paper. Just trade down and fill your treasury with IA goods
Praeceptor
Marquis
Hi Byeordie. I certainly don't mean you - and I didn't mean that a mathematical mistake had been made. What I mean is that the points value of goods donated is unbalanced. Many players will just build paper mills because the points return per square is better than that from higher age goods buildings if roads/happiness etc is taken into account.
I should have made it clearer. Sorry.
Praeceptor
Marquis
Good point, but that's always assuming there's enough people to take up the inevitable flood of trades in the market.
I should also say that although I've questioned the balance of point rewards in this thread, it's one hell of a lot better than it was, so credit due for that!
HuscarlTW
Squire
I feel like the higher-age goods should be worth a bit more than they currently are, but all in all it seems fine. I don't think it's feasible to trade thousands of paper to iron age goods. Overall, I think the three biggest changes the new ranking system will have are:
1. People will be more reluctant to trade goods upwards at old trade ratios.
2. More people will ghost on GvG since that's the #1 way to collect points.
3. People will stop buying the new premium houses/production buildings since the increased production has no impact on ranking.
1. People will be more reluctant to trade goods upwards at old trade ratios.
2. More people will ghost on GvG since that's the #1 way to collect points.
3. People will stop buying the new premium houses/production buildings since the increased production has no impact on ranking.
DeletedUser6881
Guest
Aren't premium houses/production buildings worth more points though than non-premium?
HuscarlTW
Squire
I think they're worth 2x the points of non-premium buildings of the same size. But it's a static number and is easily ignored in the context of all the points you get from battling. Building 1 tree house hotel is worth something like 20 Future battles. I could be wrong, but I doubt people would pay $5 for a building that gives points equal to 20 battles. (they are worth less population than arcologies, too.)
DeletedUser2752
Guest
That makes me much more relieved
Sorry if I sounded a bit offensive. And yes, I also believe that the points are too close together.
Last edited by a moderator: