Emberguard
Emperor
Personally I think that's better than before.
The "locked" net is still so close in shade to everything it blends in. A darker shade for the background would make the net easier to see
-
Dear forum reader,
To actively participate in our forum discussions or to start your own threads, in addition to your game account you need a forum account. You can REGISTER HERE!
Please ensure a translation in to English is provided if your post is not in English and to respect your fellow players when posting.
Feedback Soccer Cup 2023
- Thread starter Juber
- Start date
Personally I think that's better than before.
The "locked" net is still so close in shade to everything it blends in. A darker shade for the background would make the net easier to see
Kronan
Viceroy
Juber - thanks for championing the changes.... I think we're closer, but not yet there. Still having trouble, conceptually, with the FINISHED symbol. I DO like the 2 contrasting generators - but look at these, and see if this idea might work.
What you have now:
As you can see, when I combine DARK and LIGHT - I get something visually close to light, only differentiated by the "sparkles" of white. Not enough, IMHO.
Now this perspective:
or possibly even this: 
or even this (yin-yang): 
Show genesis design (dark and light aka black and white) and then show a CHECKMARK signaling completion. Color independent (so as to value people that are colorblind), but a checkmark is a universal OK symbol - ie, you've achieved the culmination you wanted from a union of dark/light (aka black/white).
Food for thought
What you have now:
As you can see, when I combine DARK and LIGHT - I get something visually close to light, only differentiated by the "sparkles" of white. Not enough, IMHO.
Now this perspective:
or possibly even this: or even this (yin-yang): Show genesis design (dark and light aka black and white) and then show a CHECKMARK signaling completion. Color independent (so as to value people that are colorblind), but a checkmark is a universal OK symbol - ie, you've achieved the culmination you wanted from a union of dark/light (aka black/white).
Food for thought
Last edited:
The new icons are faster for my brain to process, even if they don't make a lot of sense as to what they're combining. (feels like empty badge + full badge = bigger-badge more than an outside and an inside).
My last wish in terms of the visuals would be to stick to the layout where all the players are crammed against the right side. So that the spawner isn't hiding loose pieces in the middle of all the frozen ones.
My last wish in terms of the visuals would be to stick to the layout where all the players are crammed against the right side. So that the spawner isn't hiding loose pieces in the middle of all the frozen ones.
UBERhelp1
Viceroy
Yes. It's hard to keep track of what's been spawned inside the nets.
Just for a thought, instead of green field, give option to select field with three color choice. This can be included very easily.
Colour choice:
Green, Black and Sand colours.
Colour choice:
Green, Black and Sand colours.
Would love to see the dark mode variant. Dark background + bright pieces is giving the best contrast. customisability like @SlytherinAttack suggested could be a great enhancement for events like this.
I would rather like to see in addition a little more though. More accessibility options for colour blindness. Most every day devices have this and it would take only once a bit more work to make but makes a world of difference for those with such conditions.
I would rather like to see in addition a little more though. More accessibility options for colour blindness. Most every day devices have this and it would take only once a bit more work to make but makes a world of difference for those with such conditions.
Pass Go
Squire
the change from 1/2 and1/2 to full shape really threw me for a loop.. I thought I had a bunch done overnight by themselves ! once I read the announcement I can see what to do, but the finished badges(especially the yellow ones) are still hard to tell.. maybe adding a checkmark to it would help
Last edited:
ArklurBeta
Baronet
The new design is definitely better, though...the "finished" one could be a little bit more outstanding...replace the little icon with a football, no need to keep the separate color for that one? Something like this, rough version:
Or just no icon at all
ArklurBeta
Baronet
Why I didn't think about that! Yes, 100% much better, small icons could easily indicate they are missing something, they are not being there means nothing is missing, they just need to be leveled up.
Emberguard
Emperor
Spawned pieces start out with no icon
No, was a bad idea... Forgot that the spawned ones so not have an icon either
Gedrog
Squire
I don't know about the rest of the Audience I was hoping to get some store building items in the summer event and it got dropped, I hope they don't drop it from this event. We have daily special buildings that produces fragments of One up Reno finish special BP's etc how about more buildings that produce store building fragments
Silly Beaver
Merchant
Still a tangled mess. Tried to combine pieces but would not give the large icon. Even collected extra pieces thinking I missed the stacking somehow. Still no large icon. Stop rushing these games to fill the schedule and try pregame graphics out in the forum before launching the game.
nice2haveu
Baronet
With few modifications it will work out with no icons perfectly.
Spawned icon
Completed icon with 4 stars
so latest update with this modification avoid big confusion and no need to look for small icon with 4 stars. But still need to be checked for 3 stars with completed icon which is okay I feel.
It’s possible to get some through GE quit consistently nowadays.
Emberguard
Emperor
Somehow I think that'd be even more confusing than the current symbol. Too close in pattern and colour to the elements surrounding itCompleted icon with 4 stars
so latest update with this modification avoid big confusion and no need to look for small icon with 4 stars
I love the concept, just not the execution
nice2haveu
Baronet
I agree(it's not a good design and not very attractive too). Just tried to give example illustrating the point of having no icon. Some good design change will help to go with no icon concept. For good design, dev team can grind their brain. But it is clearly possible and work out very well.