Feedback PvP Arena

[Zeitlose]

you select it the same way you select the city defense army, instead of blue it's yellow

 

[coolyfooly]

you attack
they defend

so they don't use CoA and zeus and CDM

I all reayd stated they have event buildings that give much higher stats for defending armies for thoes who will say they not used.... But i think they may have it backwards, the attck symbol seems to match with there defense for defending army and the shield symbol seems to match up with there defense for defending army.

 

[sirblu]

Will I continue to lose player points even if I do not set a defending army? I want nothing to do with this pile of crap!!!

 

[Hiep Lin]

Will I continue to lose player points even if I do not set a defending army? I want nothing to do with this pile of crap!!!

If you do not participate you will have 0 points but you will not see it. (you will not be in the ranking - you will not see this ranking!)

 

[shad2389]

https://prnt.sc/tgwrmo

just did that and unless i hear that they'v added manual fight and beter prizes i won't set up a new army for it

 

[Hiep Lin]

If I go to the last page of the ranking it displays "105".
If I go back a page it displays "205".
Each time you move a page with the arrow it increases by 100.

 

[Teak]

View attachment 5688
pls implement a separate tab for both def armies- this is really awkward for fighting fast. Both battlegrounds and gvg.

And pls not as the first Tab .... would be a great opportunity to implement „favorite unit tab“

 

[airadir]

I have people in my PVP arena that are in virtual future and I am in PME that doesnt seem fair as my troops have no chance against someone so many ages ahead

 

[Fenix]

At lest I have an option... this is a joke.

 

[Markus Stormrider]

at least you still get ranking points when fighting a neighbor but i suppose thats the next feature that will disappear (so byebye people who fight in GvG and GBG just to increase their scores )

 

[sirblu]

If I go to the last page of the ranking it displays "105".
If I go back a page it displays "205".
Each time you move a page with the arrow it increases by 100.

Mine only increases by 10 to a maximum of 205 - I cannot see anyone with a score of less than 6500

 

[Hilary Briss]

Assuming PvP Arena is staying, for which I cannot really see a reason at the minute:
Sort the matching algorithm. This is such a basic error that it is should never have gotten as far as beta testing.
Choosing a defensive army... if it is the same AI as for normal PvP battles, then losing points for losing fights you effectively have no control over is not acceptable, as the PvP defensive AI is a running joke.
Bring back the PvP towers, just don't give us the medals
What happens if you inadvertently lose all of the troops for your PvP Arena defence but don't realise it as you cannot see them in the normal army screen.
No 200 point battles several times in a row...; yet another element of luck if you are actually trying to do well vs. those who get more 200 points battles than you do.

I won't go on, and I won't bother reading more feedback until an announcement is made about it being changed significantly or removed. All this grief for just a few battles a day.

 

[Claus20]

Do you intend to remove GVG from the game?

 

[shad2389]

Do you intend to remove GVG from the game?

they never said they'd remove it , would be a big error

 

[Umbrathor]

Here are a couple of additional questions:

I assume that all battles in the PvP tower will be one wave battles, but is that true?

So, if I can battle past the attrition barrier in GbG with autobattle doing 2 wave battles, in what world would my troops ever lose in a single wave PvP tower battle?

You forget that you are up against playrs who can have a very high att/def bonus for their troops, which is not necessarily comparable with what you get in GBG.

 

[Umbrathor]

If this new system is an Opt in situation have it run a match making code. You and I join the PvP tower at the same time and click find a match. then it pairs two players that are on at the same time, both players are attackers and so they both get the same bonuses.

Great idea. An active, real PvP mode is missing in the game.

 

[Claus20]

What is this new PvP? Do you want to kill the game? Do you want to turn it into a gambling game? Where is the strategy?

 

[Arwaren]

some of my thoughts ...
1. The situation where we do not see the enemy army and can only use the automatic battle is terrible.
It can't be that we don't see the opponent's army and we can only choose automatic fight. Even in a football event, we could see an opponent's soccer players and choose our soccer players to get the highest percentage possible. Because I do not see what the opponent who is in an era higher than me has for the army I am afraid to fight. We know AI is stupid. If I could manually fight I could:
Give up and lose points but my units survived or try to win
Solution:
We see the opponent's army before the fight and we fight automatically.
or
We don't see the enemy army and we fight manually
2. Why "Bonus Chest" is the same for every place?
And why should we get coins or supplies? We already have a lot of it. Nobody uses Coins Boost or Supplies Boost ... they are trash and this tower should not give it. This chest should be "Forge Points Chest", where we have a 100% chance of getting forge points.
Example:
First place - 100 forge points (100% chance)
Second place - 75 forge points (100% chance)
Third place - 50 forge points (100% chance)
#4-#50 - 25 forge points (100% chance)
#51 - #100.000 10 forge points (100% chance)
3. For place #1 - #10 there should be a chest "Military Tower Chest" where:
50% chance - Military Tower Selection Kit (Sentinel Outpost, Tactician's Tower, Watchfire)
50% chance - Military Tower Upgrade Kit ( Sentinel Outpost Upgrade Kit, Tactician's Tower Upgrade Kit, Watchfire Upgrade Kit)
This would increase interest in the arena.

 

[Azertonn]

This is completely different from what is announced .... and what will happen on Monday ..... and from what will be definitively implemented.

Of course it is different. That is the point. I am suggesting how they could implant actual PvP

 

[Zeitlose]

alrighty, I am in Colonial and I dared a fight against SAAP. Well, the opponent had a full army, of course I lost. *lol*

So yeah, a manual battle mode is badly needed. I could have at least saved my troops by retreat.