Feedback Guild Forum Removal

[jovada]

Again a new feature removing an older good working , i really wonder if the current devs ever played this game.

Move important things to the guildtab ???
First it's viewable by all members , contents that were only ment for leaders in the guild forum are then public for all members.

Second mark your topic as important , the topic will not dissapear but the messages inside will after 60 days, so a welcometext for new members that we saved on the forum and use every time a new member joins will be gone after 60 days, if you have a list of blacklisted players only readable for leaders you can't hide it.

Third if you make a topic for only leaders on the social you can't mark it as important and it will dissapear also after 60 days.

I thought this new message centrum was for making things easier for everyone, but this way you oblige us to create an extern forum for leaders.

 

[pit100]

Bitte nicht das Gilden Forum löschen, wurde bestimmt schon erwähnt da steck so viel Geschichte drin im Forum einer Gilde. Wäre schade wenn das alles weg fällt, last den schwach sinn.

 

[Dan 77]

What about guild rights? The "Trusty" will be for GvG only?

And the "Moderator" role will no longer exist, or this role will get a new purpose, for example for editing/removing messages?

https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/message-center-changes.13403/post-110469

 

[Yekk]

A much better solution would be a new forum accessible by all guild members with the old forums existing for a week after the new one goes live. Founders can migrate important threads over.

As usual plan A is a bust...How about a plan B instead...

 

[Tanmay11]

even though guild forum isn't used much, it offers a record about people who are no longer playing but have had important contributions in building up of the guild. its nice to look at the old posts.

guess the decision has already been made...but can we atleast have a new tab in msg center that would act like a forum?

 

[antoto51]

Bitte nicht das Gilden Forum löschen, wurde bestimmt schon erwähnt da steck so viel Geschichte drin im Forum einer Gilde. Wäre schade wenn das alles weg fällt, last den schwach sinn.

translate : Please do not delete the guild forum, it was probably already mentioned that there is so much history in the forum of a guild. It would be a shame if all this falls away, last the weak sense.

What about guild rights? The "Trusty" will be for GvG only?

yes, no doubt, this is already the case for most Guilds not using the forum

And the "Moderator" role will no longer exist, or this role will get a new purpose, for example for editing/removing messages?

you use it to delete, mark favorites or block messages in "Guild"

guess the decision has already been made...but can we atleast have a new tab in msg center that would act like a forum?

it is, I believe, the goal of the "Guild" part, it is for that that there is the "important" and "block the answers"

 

[Umbrathor]

I addition to the arguments @Artubar provided: the Guild Forum is part of the Guild's history. Some forums contain posts by people who have passed away, in the literal sense. All that history of the people who have founded and contributed to the Guild will be lost.

The amount of server space saved by this be substantial.

Please reconsider this decision.

 

[Miepie]

Removing the guild forum is a bit like removing the guild history. Not a good idea. Better idea would be to make the forum available for app players

 

[antoto51]

or simply not to change anything, like that no gain but no loss either (and no job for the developers)

 

[Cardena]

If a guild has used he guild forum for about 6 to 7 yeears, there should be much more than 5 topics. So how to you squeeze all of them in just 5 messages?

And in the forum one could delete a single post (because misleading, in the wrong place, of no use and interest anymore) but you cannot delete a single post from the message thread. So how should one make those as readable?

 

[Owl II]

It seems FOE is reborn from a browser game to a mobile app only little by little. Chat, PVP, Forum. But it’s not working out so well. And there is one more feature is only available in the browser version. Looks like we're going to need sooo much popcorn

 

[Devilsangel]

Going live on the 5th of October...or disappearing from live would be a better phrasing

 

[jovada]

Again 1 week passed and not a single reaction from FOE on our questions, maybe not enough complaints , must we need 90 pages again ??
Will inno do something about the guild forum or do they just not care about the guilds and their history ??
Only 1 week left.

 

[Dudettas]

I have passed on your feedback, and when I have an update I will let you know.

 

[Tigertjheu]

I hope its being good news Dont want to lose the guild-forum as well.

 

[mcbluefire]

Too soon. Wait until the features are added to make message center more like a forum. At the very least lift the 5 important thread limit and 20 lines limit. Also implement important in social threads.

 

[Fenix]

Today in my live server:


Google translation:

The current Guild Forum will be disabled on October 5, 2020. This means that all topics contained in the Guild Forum will be eliminated from the game. In order not to lose them, we recommend that you move all content from the Guild Forum to the Guild tab in the Message Center. Please check the announcement on the forum for more information!

 

[Nessie]

Google translation:

The current Guild Forum will be disabled on October 5, 2020. This means that all topics contained in the Guild Forum will be eliminated from the game. In order not to lose them, we recommend that you move all content from the Guild Forum to the Guild tab in the Message Center. Please check the announcement on the forum for more information!

Again a decision that ignores what most players think about it.

Guild forum = GUILD HISTORY

Guild forum = many useful information

Guild forum = leaders can communicate privately, without the other guild members and can read what has been discussed even after years - sometimes very helpful!


All this does not fit in a message center bolted together sort of shoddy

 

[mcbluefire]

Unbelievable. Moving forward on October 5th in live regardless of the feedback provided here. Why even bother asking for feedback?

 

[JosefD]

Hello??? Hello??? Does anyone from Inno read what people write here?

If they had they wouldn't have announced today that they want to remove the forums from the live servers as well.

Why, dear Inno, are you asking for feedback when you continuously disregard it anyway??

Anyway, you did it the wrong way round. You should FIRST have asked for feedback and THEN made a decision based on the feedback. That's the way these things normally go!