How does the Ideas section work?

[Arkantos]

I created an idea:
https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/additional-bonus-in-the-castle-system.16179/
Moderators rejected it with the reason: "Unfortunately, due to a lack of support, I cannot pass this idea along."
What kind of support are they referring to? Who should support it, players, moderators, or someone else?

 

[Fire Witch]

You need support from other players through upvotes.

 

[CrashBoom]

the voting in the right side: +1
that was not enough

the funny thing about the voting result is:

+4 "I am happy to forward this."
submitted: https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/a-change-to-the-tavern-boost.16109/

+4 "Unfortunately due to a lack of support I cannot pass this idea along."
rejected:

https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/ability-to-mute-people-in-guild%E2%80%99s-threads.16017/

so +4 is obviously not +4

 

[Arkantos]

You need support from other players through upvotes.

How long does the voting last?

 

[Deleted User - 57457]

so +4 is obviously not +4

Obviously you need 3 upvotes

https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.c...fragment-items-to-last-pages-inventory.16143/

Hmmm, I must be really bad at math but if an proposal with 3 upvotes gets forwarded, a proposal with 4 upvotes gets rejected and simultaneously a proposal with 4 upvotes gets rejected... something doesn't adds up. Shouldn't there be made universal guidelines? Like X upvotes needed to be forwarded, Y weeks to gather support or something after which new proposals are closed automatically?

 

[CrashBoom]

Obviously you need 3 upvotes

https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.c...fragment-items-to-last-pages-inventory.16143/

actually that one wasn't forwarded

it only was marked as forwarded because other ideas with same topic were already forwarded

Therefore the basic problem (too many fragments, cluttered inventory) of this suggestion has been forwarded already through other ideas and event feedback.

I'll close this thread now and treat it as forwarded.

.

 

[nice2haveu]

You need support from other players through upvotes.

Without votes also ideas forwarded earlier!!
Is that due to covid pandemic situation?

 

[Fire Witch]

How long does the voting last?

It depends, we try to collect ideas monthly, but it does not always work out that regularly. If the idea has not been around for so long, we'll wait until the next month.

Without votes also ideas forwarded earlier!!
Is that due to covid pandemic situation?

What do you mean exactly?


If the idea is in a certain range of upvotes we can decide if it will be forwarded or not.

 

[Battle Tomcat]

the voting in the right side: +1
that was not enough

the funny thing about the voting result is:

+4 "I am happy to forward this."
submitted: https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/a-change-to-the-tavern-boost.16109/

+4 "Unfortunately due to a lack of support I cannot pass this idea along."
rejected:

https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/ability-to-mute-people-in-guild%E2%80%99s-threads.16017/

so +4 is obviously not +4

If the idea is in a certain range of upvotes we can decide if it will be forwarded or not.

@Fire Witch
What is the range? If you can share this info...
It would be super nice to explain a bit in respective idea thread why "we can decide" is/was once UP once DOWN with same amount of upvotes.

 

[Fire Witch]

What is the range? If you can share this info...
It would be super nice to explain a bit in respective idea thread why "we can decide" is/was once UP once DOWN with same amount of upvotes.

We'll discuss and get back to you

 

[Deleted User - 241425]

What shocks me most about the current system is that whoever makes a suggestion can't even vote for their suggestion and I've seen suggestions end in a tie and be denied.

 

[Velvet Thunder]

What is the range? If you can share this info...
It would be super nice to explain a bit in respective idea thread why "we can decide" is/was once UP once DOWN with same amount of upvotes

At least a minimum of 4 support is needed for us to consider forwarding it.

Without votes also ideas forwarded earlier!!
Is that due to covid pandemic situation?

All the ideas with 0 net support were from before the new system was implemented (August 2022). Unfortunately all preexisting polls were automatically deleted. Of course they were forwarded because they had significant community support.

How long does the voting last?

This depends. Ideas that are gaining positive traction are given at least a week. There is no upper limit as it depends on when we clear the backlog which ideally should be monthly but doesn't always end up being so. Note that when processing these we also close suggestions which are DNS, or gaining negative support at one go.

the funny thing about the voting result is:

+4 "I am happy to forward this."
submitted: https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/a-change-to-the-tavern-boost.16109/

+4 "Unfortunately due to a lack of support I cannot pass this idea along."
rejected:

https://forum.beta.forgeofempires.com/index.php?threads/ability-to-mute-people-in-guild%E2%80%99s-threads.16017/

so +4 is obviously not +4

See, as mentioned earlier at least 4 support is required. But in some cases we have to exercise our own judgement and consider factors like how long the idea has been open for, comments and reactions on the thread etc. Everything is not always about the numbers. Anyways that mute idea was already suggested from another market in July 2021.

 

[Arkantos]

Tell me, how likely is it that any idea will be implemented to solve the problem with the sliding timer? Several solutions to this problem were suggested in my topic. I have been following the Russian-language forum foe for a long time. I don't know about here, but we constantly see topics requesting a solution to this problem. Usually, the admins reject them, but the idea I mentioned here was "Forwarded" by our admins and it received 69 votes in support.

https://forum.ru.forgeofempires.com...avit-eschjo-odin-bonus-v-sistemu-zamka.15681/

And even judging by the comments in my topic, many people don't like this sliding timer. It's just that my own idea was not well-received.

I'm just trying to understand if it's worth my time and effort to try to convey the message that the sliding timer is a serious problem.

Translation done with ChatGPT. I apologize if there are any errors in spelling or grammar.

 

[joyfulrider]

voting is flawed, why because showing negative vote values.
if 2 supports and 2 denies, count is zero.
if 6 supports and 3 denies, count is positive three.
if 5 support and 8 denies, count is negative three.

I want the presidential election vote to be performed like this.