Rejected New achievement for not plundering

[BeeVee]

Reason

Players do not have the possibility to express they are proud they don't plunder

Details

After a certain amount of days the player hasn't plundered a city the achievement is granted.
Level 1 : After 1 days
Level 2 : After 5 days
Level 3 : After 20 days
Level 4 : After 50 days
Level 5 : After 100 days

The name of the achievements could be: Make Peace, No War

Balance

This will have almost zero impact on other game futures
Maybe the palyerhave to choose between gaining this achievement and effectiveness of certain GB

Abuse Prevention

No abuse is possible

Summary

As opposite of the achievements that counts how many times a player has plundered a city.
This new achievement counts how long the player did not plunder a city

Have you looked to see if this has already been suggested?

Yes

Nowadays players can only indicate they are proud on how many times they plundered a city.
I suggest they can express that they are proud they don't plunder

 

[Iggy the Troll]

I'd like to suggest some alternate ideas for the name.

1. Nice Guys Finish Last
2. Miss Congeniality
3. Gamer Vegan (it's not enough to not plunder, you must also tell everyone that you come in contact with that you don't plunder)

 

[Pericles the Lion]

A merit badge for not plundering. Hmm. I think not.

 

[Ironrooster]

I like the idea. But let's call it Friend to All.

A merit badge for not plundering. Hmm. I think not.

Hey if we can have a merit badge for stealing, why not one for not stealing?

 

[Pericles the Lion]

I like the idea. But let's call it Friend to All.

Hey if we can have a merit badge for stealing, why not one for not stealing?

Maybe call it "Catch and Release"?

 

[DEADP00L]

Then it will be a badge with the number of days without logging in?
Then a badge for X fights without camps?
Then a badge for not sniping?

 

[Macha]

i think if its a badge for not plundering then the player needs to have attacked & won & made the choice to not plunder, this idea is a not attacking badge which is different to not plundering
maybe it should have the same figures as the plunder badge, eg the plunder badges are plunder 20/250/1500/3000 buildings so theses badges should be dont plunder 20/250/1500/3000 cities

 

[Thunderdome]

I upvoted because the game looks like it can use some more things...

 

[CrashBoom]

the times are definitely too low
less than 4 month to reach highest level in a game which is designed to played for years

maybe
Level 1 : 1 month
Level 2 : 6 month
Level 3 : 1 year
Level 4 : 2 years
Level 5 : 3 years

because

Players do not have the possibility to express they are proud they don't plunder

1 day wouldn't be something to be proud
but 3 years is

Then a badge for not sniping?

I want a badge for biggest snipe
level 5: 1000 FP (or more)

 

[Emberguard]

This new achievement counts how long the player did not plunder a city

If the players plunders, does it then reset to 0? Is this "time since last plunder"? OR, "longest time period without plundering"?

 

[BeeVee]

I think it should act like quests like: win 12 battles without loosing. Resetting after each plunder.

 

[CrashBoom]

I think it should act like quests like: win 12 battles without loosing. Resetting after each plunder.

resetting the counter but keeping the achievement level

like the amount of FP spend per day achievement

 

[DEADP00L]

If badges mean so much to you, why not claim that they are all visible instead of the 3 that everyone can select?
If the badges can provide useful information about YOUR way of playing, then it would make sense that we could then see them all.

 

[CrashBoom]

If badges mean so much to you, why not claim that they are all visible instead of the 3 that everyone can select?
If the badges can provide useful information about YOUR way of playing, then it would make sense that we could then see them all.

that is why I suggested an achievement ranking for each of them in the past

so players can check how they perform in the categories of their playing style

didn't get enough upvotes

 

[Sorcino]

Hi

I do not agree . I do not post any improvements to the game .. I do not think it represents a possible implementation useful for the purposes of the game.

Greetings
Sorcino

 

[Dessire]

It should not be a matter of days but of the number of neughbors you have motivated.

If yo stop playing for 10 days, those are 10 days of no activity, not of plundering.

 

[Emberguard]

but of the number of neughbors you have motivated.

Aiding other players is already a achievement of its own, and Aiding isn't required to not plunder a neighbour

 

[.Chris]

It would only makes sense is it counts "Attacked but NOT plundered"
Just days without plundering is worthless

 

[Kronan]

Unless I'm mistaken, achievement badges have ZERO game value, other than ....In my mind, it was a original game designer idea that's about as important to the MODERN game as your appendix is to your MODERN body.

Or the tavern goods merchant is to the MODERN game, too. Or the event HUB is to the MODERN GAME (may it rest in peace).

This is called "game clutter". Vestigial ideas/features that don't deliver anything, have no practical value, and are buried in ancient areas of the game that no one cares about.

Inno engineering could consider ripping it ALL out (probably a blessing...), but it certainly shouldn't resurrect it, embellish it, or continue to spend money on it through graphic design, and software engineering.

 

[CrashBoom]

achievement badges have ZERO game value

like the ranking