• Dear forum reader,
    To actively participate in our forum discussions or to start your own threads, in addition to your game account you need a forum account. You can
    REGISTER HERE!
    Please ensure a translation in to English is provided if your post is not in English and to respect your fellow players when posting.
  • Halloween Event 2021


    Read all about the Halloween Event 2021 here!
  • Castle System

    The Castle System is a brand new feature in Forge of Empires which aims to reward players that are playing Forge of Empires actively. Come check it out in your city!
    Do you want to know more about this new feature? Then click here!
  • Cultural Settlement - Mughal Empire

    We are proud to present you our brand new Cultural Settlement: The Mughal Empire!
    This is the fifth of our Cultural Settlements, and your job is to help expand the Mughal Embassy.
    Read all about it here!

Ideas for changes in GvG

Do you agree to add the diamonds to the guild treasury for use in GBG?

  • YES

    Votes: 3 37.5%
  • NO

    Votes: 5 62.5%

  • Total voters
    8

alm1983

Farmer
Sorry for my English I use google translator

Creation of a treasure in the diamond guild to use in GvG. In addition to a treasure trove of goods and medals, diamonds would be added.
 
Reason
This change aims to generate new and diverse strategies on the GvG map throughout the day, in addition to expanding the purchase of diamonds from the part of the players that benefits Innogames by generating more income.
Details
1- That the guild has a treasure of diamonds. At the beginning they can only be donated by their members to the treasury. Then it can be implemented that they are contributed by a new Great Building or by a special building such as the Statue of Honor.
2- With these diamonds you can move the Headquarters only 1 time a day extra to the free movement on each GvG map. Cost of the share 500 diamonds.
3- To be able to extend the protection of 1 sector conquered for 24 more hours. It will only be valid for sectors that already had protection and it will not be possible to use more than 1 time until said sector loses protection. Cost of the action 100 diamonds.
4- Be able to attack 1 sector with protection. Cost of the action 200 diamonds.
Balance
Buildings can be incorporated into the game to collect diamonds whose only use is the donation to the guild's treasury. Since these diamonds cannot be used by the players. Also these changes will bring more fun to the game in GvG.
Abuse Prevention
No
Summary
It is a change that must be studied before rejecting it.
Have you looked to see if this has already been suggested?
No
Last edited:
Diamonds added to the Guild Treasury would be then available for GBG. If Idea get trashed to the DNSL then post this part as a new idea without any reference to GvG.
 
Last edited:

CrashBoom

Emperor
DNSL
Changes/Additions to GvG.

:rolleyes:

Summary: It is a change that must be studied before rejecting it.
it is a change that is already rejected because of DNSL


and the poll is also invalid because breaking the poll rules
 
Then option to salvage something of this is create a new idea for the part of donating Diamonds by the Players to the Guild Treasury.
  1. Without reference to GvG to avoid trashing to DSNL
  2. With proper idea formating / poll rules.
 

CrashBoom

Emperor
Without reference to GvG to avoid trashing to DSNL
the idea would then be from 4 points to simply
That the guild has a treasure of diamonds. can only be donated by their members to the treasury.
because the rest is forbidden:
list of forbidden things

Then it can be implemented that they are contributed by a new Great Building or by a special building such as the Statue of Honor.
DNSL: GB
DNSL: Easier access to Diamonds. Diamonds are rare for a reason.

2- With these diamonds you can move the Headquarters only 1 time a day extra to the free movement on each GvG map. Cost of the share 500 diamonds.
3- To be able to extend the protection of 1 sector conquered for 24 more hours. It will only be valid for sectors that already had protection and it will not be possible to use more than 1 time until said sector loses protection. Cost of the action 100 diamonds.
4- Be able to attack 1 sector with protection. Cost of the action 200 diamonds.
GvG: DNSL

and just wondering about
Since these diamonds cannot be used by the players.
who will spend the diamonds from the treasury if not the players?
 
Last edited:
who will spend the diamonds from the treasury if not the players?
The treatment for Diamonds at the Treasury would be the same as usage of Medals donated to the Treasury.
  • Player donates Diamonds from the balance available at his/her account.
  • Once at the Treasury, diamonds would be used only for guild related activities requiring diamonds, like for example speed construction of sieges at GBG.
  • Only Players with proper rights assigned will be able to use these diamonds.
  • Diamonds from Treasury would not be available for private uses like buying an expansion for a city.
 

alm1983

Farmer
The main objective of the proposal is the changes in GvG. To achieve these changes requires a change in the contribution of diamonds to the treasury. It makes no sense to change the contribution of diamonds to the treasury without changes in GvG

I just opened a new topic. If necessary close this
 
Last edited:

CrashBoom

Emperor
The main objective of the proposal is the changes in GvG.
that is still DNSL

It makes no sense to change the contribution of diamonds to the treasury without changes in GvG
but there won't be any changes in GvG

the development for GvG is dead
(even if it is still there and won't get removed)

I just opened a new topic.
and again called "... GvG"
also won't make it to the developers

next time maybe a little bit smarter
"diamond treasury for use in guild activities"

so not being only GvG related
but everywhere guild related places: GBG, GEx (buying goods with diamonds when not enough in treasury for next level), what else will come for the guild and cost diamonds

and then adding GvG at the end of list for already existing use there (if anybody exist)
so nobody actually would think GvG is any important in the idea. only to have all ways where guilds can use diamonds
 

CrashBoom

Emperor
TITLE: guild treasury for diamonds

Description
Creation of a treasure in the diamond guild to use in guild activites. In addition to a treasure trove of goods and medals, diamonds would be added.

Reason:
people can help the guild with donating diamonds at any time they want
so they must not be online when those diamonds actually are needed to be spend

Details:
everywhere diamonds can be used in guild activites (GBG,GE,GvG,...) they are first used from treasury. only when it is empty personal diamonds are used



and voila
not an "idea vor changes in GvG"
but a valid idea only mentioning GvG once in the list of guild activities