Feedback Halloween Event 2024

[SlytherinAttack]

I am not okay with the knives random pick in spin wheel board.

Instead, they could have kept normal board without spin wheel and the prize items kept hidden in a box where the players pick the box (click or touch) knife will be thrown automatically to reveal the prize. For 3x and 5x, players can select 3 boxes and 5 boxes in one turn where the knives thrown out immediately after the boxes exact count gets selected. With this, still neighbors can mess around where boxes get blurred when it got picked already.

 

[SlytherinAttack]

People asked for it back. Not everyone obviously, but some did.

Some did for sure, but they didn't ask to override the Halloween card game with spin wheel event. If anyone asked for it, that's a horrible request.

 

[CrashBoom]

so winning a prize with those small icon gives 5 extra progress

 

[CDmark]

keeping a list here what I see, gold and any significant silver (maybe there may be a couple, never know)

GOLD prizes
joker gold kit (guess the joke is on us, not that great)
2024 halloween kit
ascended royal carriage upgrade
ascended earth eden upgrade
ascended hub upgrade kit
monstrosities golden upgrade kit
ascended green guardians market upgrade
ascended jolly oink pigsty (confirmed ascended)
Knights Pavilion upgrade kit
ascended vegabond library upgrade
arcane tarot card golden upgrade
ascended harvest hub
ectoplasmic kit (betsy bar or monster ranch)

Silver prizes

royal carriage
jolly oink pigsty
monster wares boutique
tower of whispering horrors
stages of ages
knights pavilion

regular asylum kit
joker silver kit
monstrosities silver upgrade

100% QI boost 30 min red
100% QI boost 30 min blue
500% GBG boost red A
500% GBG boost red D
400% GBG boost red A
400% GBG boost red D
400% GE boost blue D
400% GE boost red A

FSP
mass self aid
finish all supplies (if you didn't get harvest hubs, can be handy)
store
self aid kit
one up kit
reno kit
2023 halloween kit


Notes:
had 4 silver and one gold target (5/10)
had 3 silver and one gold target (4/10)
I can say the spooky drink range is 3-6, I see more 4/5 but I have snapshot data.
There is only one spooky drink per prize. Once taken it is gone for all. So, if there are 4 military units in a common prize (green outline) and it has a spooky drink, there is only one drink there, not 4.

 

[CrashBoom]

keeping a list here what I see, gold and any significant silver (maybe there may be a couple, never know)

gold prizes
joker kit (guess the joke is on us, not that great)
2024 halloween kit
ascended royal carriage upgrade

silver
royal carriage

gold
joker GOLD kit

silver
joker SILVER kit
2023 halloween kit

 

[CDmark]

I can guess like very big nerf will be going to happen on this event. Not ready to pinpoint those, but if nothing happened means that would be amazing.

So far I counted 1 golden asylum in grand prizes and 3 on the pass up to 5900. Sniff, sniff, I smell a nerf in the air. With QI boost, this can become multiple QI boost buildings. They should make it so only one counts in your settlement, in some ways similar to only collecting once on a GBG/QI building (no FSP). Then they wouldn't have to nerf it since we would only get QI boost for 1 of them. You get the other boosts bcs you paid for them. I am not against people getting multiple QI boosts but we know who doesn't like it.

 

[xivarmy]

So far I counted 1 golden asylum in grand prizes and 3 on the pass up to 5900. Sniff, sniff, I smell a nerf in the air. With QI boost, this can become multiple QI boost buildings. They should make it so only one counts in your settlement, in some ways similar to only collecting once on a GBG/QI building (no FSP). Then they wouldn't have to nerf it since we would only get QI boost for 1 of them. You get the other boosts bcs you paid for them. I am not against people getting multiple QI boosts but we know who doesn't like it.

The only thing the previous nerf really promised was that buildings we can generate more of through FSP won't be making QI boost - lest someone make a city with dozens of them. People spending dollars to get 4 of them is something inno would happily allow

 

[drakenridder]

I am not okay with the knives random pick in spin wheel board.

Instead, they could have kept normal board without spin wheel and the prize items kept hidden in a box where the players pick the box (click or touch) knife will be thrown automatically to reveal the prize. For 3x and 5x, players can select 3 boxes and 5 boxes in one turn where the knives thrown out immediately after the boxes exact count gets selected. With this, still neighbors can mess around where boxes get blurred when it got picked already.

You mean a winter event reskin?

 

[CDmark]

The only thing the previous nerf really promised was that buildings we can generate more of through FSP won't be making QI boost - lest someone make a city with dozens of them. People spending dollars to get 4 of them is something inno would happily allow

Well, the Whisperwood got nerfed for multiple QI boost and that was one people could pay for and they did it after people paid. If they do it again, after the event, then it would be a major scam because they just did it and it is the same scenario.

 

[xivarmy]

Well, the Whisperwood got nerfed for multiple QI boost and that was one people could pay for and they did it after people paid. If they do it again, after the event, then it would be a major scam because they just did it and it is the same scenario.

It was also one with a gold league building to generate it indefinitely after the event. Which was the disqualifying factor. Asylum you only get whatever you win in the event (like Orchard of Orange Dreams that they also left alone).

 

[drakenridder]

Well, the Whisperwood got nerfed for multiple QI boost and that was one people could pay for and they did it after people paid. If they do it again, after the event, then it would be a major scam because they just did it and it is the same scenario.

That was on beta? So, on the test server or on a live server? Only big nerf I recall on the live server was with summer event.

 

[CDmark]

It was also one with a gold league building to generate it indefinitely after the event. Which was the disqualifying factor. Asylum you only get whatever you win in the event (like Orchard of Orange Dreams that they also left alone).

ok, I can see that. Plus the silver asylum doesn't make gold fragments so you HAVE TO buy gold pass if you want the full building...very sneaky...lol

 

[CDmark]

That was on beta? So, on the test server or on a live server? Only big nerf I recall on the live server was with summer event.

here in beta, live starts next week with the adjustment.

 

[xivarmy]

That was on beta? So, on the test server or on a live server? Only big nerf I recall on the live server was with summer event.

There's been multiple live nerfs recently. Very much a thing. (History = Silk Weaver no longer made by Sanctuary, road requirement removal from potentially-ascended buildings (which they took the occasion to nerf by more than was warranted for a 1/3 reduction in size - my gongs from summer on one side world). FSP nerf on QI/GBG buildings)

But the one he refers to was on beta, the event hasn't started on live yet. So the risks you take if you decide to spend on beta where such things are expected to happen at times.

 

[drakenridder]

here in beta, live starts next week with the adjustment.

Okay that makes quite a big difference. A nerf prior to live servers is somewhat acceptable and to be expected under potential (major) changes and adjustments. At live server and particularly after the event it's just a massively wicked move. Especially since as far I know they didn't offer any compensations for their mistakes when applying large nerfs post summer event at live. Long before MTG they adjusted GB's giving military buffs. To compensate for it anyone with a Zeus, Aachen or CDM was given a 1-use voucher to level them for free instantly by 1 level. Before each gave up to 50% @lvl10. Unfortunately they don't know what compensation is anymore after applying nerfs at live.

There's been multiple live nerfs recently. Very much a thing. (History = Silk Weaver no longer made by Sanctuary, road requirement removal from potentially-ascended buildings (which they took the occasion to nerf by more than was warranted for a 1/3 reduction in size - my gongs from summer on one side world). FSP nerf on QI/GBG buildings)

But the one he refers to was on beta, the event hasn't started on live yet. So the risks you take if you decide to spend on beta where such things are expected to happen at times.

I was more talking about recent nerfs at the live server. Last I know was summer event. Even after the event. That was a significant bad move on their part. During live I recall indeed the hero event been nerfed into uninteresting and not worth the space.

Let's hope they won't nerf buildings of this event. Particularly after the event ends @live

 

[WarMachineX]

There isn't a big difference in stats between the Joker Silver and Gold. I personally will stop those at Silver and not go for Gold.

 

[SlytherinAttack]

You mean a winter event reskin?

Yes and winter event should get a card game. That's what my desire.

 

[planetofthehumans2]

Yes and winter event should get a card game. That's what my desire.

Instead of that defeat the character, it should be Loteria !

 

[Thunderdome]

Do my eyes deceive me? The event on the mobile app? Or at least the minigame? And it's not even the beta app.

More to come.

 

[Juber]

All active players now received 1500 diamonds for testing.